What Happened: Dr. Jay Bhattacharya on 19 Months of COVID

Paylaş
Ekle
  • katma 20 Eki 2021
  • Recorded on October 13, 2021

    From the very beginning of the COVID-19 crisis, Dr. Jay Bhattacharya has been on the front lines of analyzing, studying, and even personally fighting the pandemic. In this wide-ranging interview, Dr. Bhattacharya takes us through how it started, how it spread throughout the world, the efficacy of lockdowns, the development and distribution of the vaccines, and the rise of the Delta variant. He delves into what we got right, what we got wrong, and what we got really wrong. Finally, Dr. Bhattacharya looks to the future and how we will learn to live with COVID rather than trying to extinguish it, and how we might be prepared to deal with another inevitable pandemic that we know will arrive at some point.

    For further information:
    www.hoover.org/publications/u...

    Interested in exclusive Uncommon Knowledge content? Check out Uncommon Knowledge on social media!

    Facebook: UncKnowledge/
    Twitter: UncKnowledge/
    Instagram: uncommon_knowle...

YORUMLAR • 0

  • Mario Gonzalez
    Mario Gonzalez 3 aylar önce +3155

    It's unbelievable to me how so many people get really upset if you try to explain these facts to them...they simply don't want to hear it...Thank you...

  • Owen Crassweller
    Owen Crassweller 3 aylar önce +2076

    Dr Battacharya's measured approach is so much more credible than the hysteria of the public health officials and many politicians.

  • Kane123
    Kane123 3 aylar önce +2554

    Jay has been one of the true heroes of this pandemic. History will look kindly on the man who was brave enough to mount a defence against all this madness.

  • Paul Armstrong
    Paul Armstrong 3 aylar önce +2769

    This man is a hero. The fact he is targeted despite his scientific credientials is nothing less than criminal.

  • sc100ott
    sc100ott 3 aylar önce +2841

    Last year, I was one of tens of thousands of physicians to co-sign the Great Barrington Declaration. Today, I am still proud of that fact. My greatest respect goes out to Dr. Bhatacharya (apologies for spelling), his collaborators on the GBD, and to Dr. Scott Atlas, who I know is on the same page.

    • ziggy
      ziggy 2 aylar önce +201

      Thank You Doctor for.being on Correct Side of History.
      Godspeed to you and your kind.
      🙏

    • gnorweb
      gnorweb 2 aylar önce +228

      Thanks, I am not a medical professional but I could clearly see that this was not a significant issue that warranted the response it got. It has been truly eye opening to see the scale of human stupidity and the resilience of the economy. I am in different ways hopeful for, and fearful of the future. Thank you for your contribution toward sanity during a time of unprecedented madness.

    • Johan öhman
      Johan öhman 2 aylar önce +121

      Thanks for a refreshing interview that on this topic make sense for a change 😊

    • ladyesther
      ladyesther 2 aylar önce +113

      Thank you.

    • Kathy Leicester
      Kathy Leicester 2 aylar önce +401

      I'm a member of the public who's being destroyed by the communists who have taken over and destroyed every institution I used to trust, including the medical profession.
      God bless all doctors who signed Barrington. We pray for you every day, and know that eventually, right will defeat evil.
      God bless you and all your other Barrington MDs.

  • Covidity
    Covidity 3 aylar önce +1942

    Historic interview. It will be referenced for years and years.

  • Catherine Macneil
    Catherine Macneil 3 aylar önce +1124

    Thankyou from Melbourne, Australia. I wish we had such respectful and thoughtful discussions broadcast on our media here.

    • Met Girl
      Met Girl 3 aylar önce +93

      Hi from Adelaide
      Agreed !!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Dede Tudor
    Dede Tudor 3 aylar önce +993

    We're grateful for this interview.

  • Dani R
    Dani R 2 aylar önce +811

    The courage of this man to keep speaking out against the atrocities of our “scientific” community and governments in the way they have handled this pandemic, gives me hope for humanity! Thank you Jay and thank you for this interview. Everyone should hear this talk!

  • Anna Fields
    Anna Fields 2 aylar önce +521

    Thank you so much for this important interview. I am one of the millions whose livelihood was devastated by the shutdown. I was unable to receive any assistance during that time, and I’m still trying to dig my way out financially. I started 2020 with no debt, and now I’m still on the edge of losing my business with tens thousands of debt. It’s been emotionally draining and stressful, and has taken me from loving my work to dreading it. I live in Washington state, and our state’s lockdown and mandates have been horrible for businesses, while next door in Idaho, it’s been mostly business as usual. We lost many customers to Idaho, since it’s a 25 minute drive away. I really appreciate you drawing attention to the mishandling of the lockdown. I hope it does some good, and wakes some people up.

  • Gyaan Chandraa Shakya
    Gyaan Chandraa Shakya 3 aylar önce +902

    Thank you for the interview . increasing covid hysteria is looking like a mass psychosis .

  • Lifebee LifeBee
    Lifebee LifeBee 2 aylar önce +514

    Thank you for this intelligent and deep conversation. Personally, my hope to survive covid without vax is equal to my fear of getting serious side effects from vax. The scale is pretty much balanced, at least for me. In my immediate circle, I have four people age 60-80 who died from covid being fully vaccinated. It is a no for me, by now.

    • Nan
      Nan 2 aylar önce +239

      I really wish he had talked more on this. Would have loved to get his thoughts on Dr Peter McCullough, Dr Malone and others incl ex VP Pfizer Mike Yeadon and their very convincing and concerning warning on the vaccines, and also his thoughts on all the alarming safety signals showing in the Vaers data. I face losing my job over an employer mandate and so confused by conflicting information I'm hearing from seemingly genuine and highly educated medical experts. There is also no long term safety data. I am totally opposed to the propaganda and coercion and don't even know how I could continue working for a company that deems it ethical to demand coerced medical interventions on its staff. Where there is risk there should be choice.

  • mark savage
    mark savage 3 aylar önce +726

    I started following Jay in april 2020 and it has kept me sane in a world of ignorance.

  • Babs Harris
    Babs Harris 3 aylar önce +379

    Well I never did go for any spots, never had the Flu & had no intention of getting a Vaccine. Just before Thanksgiving I got Covid from my Vaccinated friend. At 88 it was pretty scary, but with no DR, NO Hospital & no one to care for me, using only needed Supplements I have survive. It was scary & costly. Some side affects very frustrating. Excess sleeping was a great benefit. Unable to care for myself or cook, not being able to eat for over 3 week's worst.

  • Mercedes Carrión
    Mercedes Carrión 2 aylar önce +297

    This was devastating. Hard to watch 😭 Brutally and painfully honest. Heart broken with everything. Thank you for your bravery. 💗

  • Robyn Cohen
    Robyn Cohen 3 aylar önce +361

    Thank you Dr Batacharaya for your courage during this time of profound intellectual deceipt from governments, the media, and corporates entities worldwide

  • Julie Beth Ramsdell
    Julie Beth Ramsdell 2 aylar önce +257

    This discussion has restored my faith in humanity. Perhaps there is hope. Thank you, Dr Jay.

  • tonedawg1983
    tonedawg1983 2 aylar önce +383

    This was fascinating, thank you very much for this level headed interview. One thing I wish you touched on was the vaccination of children and young adults and the issue of Myocarditis.

    • ian bardon
      ian bardon 2 aylar önce +80

      Another interview is required re so called Vaccine s, these are shots with many different outcomes.

    • Nan
      Nan 2 aylar önce +140

      Yes I 100% agree.
      I'm wish I could get his thoughts on Dr Peter McCullough, Dr Malone and others incl ex VP Pfizer Mike Yeadon and their very convincing and concerning warning on the vaccines, and also his thoughts on all the alarming safety signals showing in the Vaers data. I face losing my job over an employer mandate and so confused by conflicting information I'm hearing from seemingly genuine and highly educated medical experts. There is also no long term safety data. I am totally opposed to the propaganda and coercion and don't even know how I could continue working for a company that deems it ethical to demand coerced medical interventions on its staff. Where there is risk there should be choice.

  • Vira Mandybur
    Vira Mandybur 3 aylar önce +461

    Jay Bhattacharya...a brave voice of integrity. Thank you for your continued commitment to truth and science.

  • magnus kwaszenko
    magnus kwaszenko 3 aylar önce +290

    Such a good interview, and what a gracious, thoughtful man, Jay Bhattacharya is. One hopes that as a result of rigorous analysis of dynamics, decisions made, policies implemented and public pronouncements given, a much more effective and multilevelled consideration of the actions needed in the next pandemic will emerge. Thank you both.

  • Mark Stanton
    Mark Stanton 3 aylar önce +528

    Brilliant men. Everything discussed makes so much sense, although I wish they would have addressed children's vaccinations.

  • Cody Bench
    Cody Bench 3 aylar önce +152

    The creation and response to this whole thing is criminal. Thank you Jay for being honest. Although the damage continues, Thank you.

  • Victoria Ward
    Victoria Ward 3 aylar önce +662

    Thank you soooo much!!! The Great Barrington Declaration was a light in the darkness when it was first published in Summer 2020. And it still makes perfect sense now, over a year later. It isn't built on whims and knee-jerk reactions but the principles of proper public health. Oh, may we soon return to those.

  • Aces Maven
    Aces Maven 3 aylar önce +151

    I'm so glad that Peter interviews the way he does. Makes it easier for the rest of us to understand too. Wonderful interview as always! I always get excited to see Peter and his guests. Oh how I wish Dr. B had been in charge of the task force. How much better off we would have been. Unsure if some states would have listened. I'm glad he is still speaking out. Bless you Dr. B and thanks for another great interview Peter!

  • ANN HOOVER
    ANN HOOVER 2 aylar önce +101

    Can't say thank you enough for this interview. Finally heard what feels like truth - rational, drama-free, unpolitical truth.

  • Tom Perrone
    Tom Perrone 3 aylar önce +249

    One of the clearest conversations to date. Thank you!

  • Claude Hutchings
    Claude Hutchings 2 aylar önce +125

    Thank you for the first common sense discussion I have seen on this matter. Im surprised the social media police haven't shut it down

  • Karrie Welch
    Karrie Welch 2 aylar önce +114

    Great work- thank you for continuing to speak- I disagree on these vaccines- we are seeing untold numbers of heart and neurological issues shortly after vaccine. The record number of top athlete deaths- many in teens and early 20’s, are horrifying.

  • Clear Vision
    Clear Vision 3 aylar önce +233

    You were such a bright light in the darkness of this "Pandemic". God bless you and yours! Old nurse here!

    • Clear Vision
      Clear Vision 3 aylar önce +37

      Dr. Battacharya that is/ Thank you for continally speakng out on this onfolding disaster.

  • Joseph
    Joseph 3 aylar önce +312

    The list of things I loved about this interview is huge. Thank you for interviewing actual experts and asking some challenging questions! The tide is turning slowly thanks to shows like this

  • PhysicsOnLine
    PhysicsOnLine 2 aylar önce +70

    This is one of the most profoundly insightful interviews I have ever come across on You Tube.Thank you for publishing it.

  • Hertha Voorhis
    Hertha Voorhis 3 aylar önce +259

    Hallelujah! I salute you for speaking truth! As a pharmacist, I have been appalled by Fauci’s control over this Covid outbreak. We health care professionals have been silenced but we are waking up and are speaking out! Thank you!

  • Neil Kerby
    Neil Kerby 2 aylar önce +343

    Thank you for all your work, I can only hope that as the facts are laid out, Anthony Fauchi and many more people who dictate to the population of the world, go to prison, no politician or scientist should be allowed to lock down a society. The WHO are not fit for purpose and are a disgrace. The damage to mental health and people's wellbeing is going to be felt for decades to come, I can only hope that this never will be allowed to happen again.

  • Nicole Smith
    Nicole Smith 3 aylar önce +245

    Whatever illness one gets when in your eighties it’s common knowledge that one is at a higher risk of dying,. Covid or no covid.These earthly bodies ware out as difficult and sad as that is; we are not in heaven yet! If one is afraid of covid they can choose to stay home but if everyone stops living, we all will die. Thank you such good common sense, at least to me. God bless

  • Ruth Nutter
    Ruth Nutter 3 aylar önce +173

    I’m riveted! Such common sense based on actual science! Thank you.

  • Babs S
    Babs S 2 aylar önce +111

    True science from scientists who actually care about humanity as a whole! Thank you so much!

  • Ines Crawford
    Ines Crawford 2 aylar önce +58

    Finally!! A reasonable, highly-qualified explanation about Covid, social, economic, political, education, medical, miscalculated health policies.
    Thank you Doctor Jay your explanations were easy to understand and convey to others.
    Thank you both!!

  • Dean Memory
    Dean Memory 3 aylar önce +113

    Thank you for such an intelligent discussion.

  • The Truth
    The Truth 3 aylar önce +155

    In person interview is night and day better than the zoom interviews. Thanks for what you do Peter.

  • vita j Coffey
    vita j Coffey 3 aylar önce +252

    What great information! Love this interview! Thank you for doing this! I have lost faith in Medicine. But this interview helped me understand that there are still some doctors who really believe in their oath to “Do no harm” and have the best interest of their patients in mind!

  • Robert Tuss
    Robert Tuss 3 aylar önce +119

    Enlightening. Thank You, Hoover Institution, Dr. Bhattacharya, and of course the inimitable Peter Robinson.

  • Joshua Lott
    Joshua Lott 3 aylar önce +230

    Dr. Jay is a very intelligent person.

  • Tropicalan
    Tropicalan 3 aylar önce +86

    I called this right from the "get go". I said, "This will not end anytime soon" once this started. I cannot, in words, express my gratitude for a common sense approach. I thank you...

  • Francisco
    Francisco 3 aylar önce +143

    What a range of intellectual awesomeness!!! I admire Dr. Bhattacharya! THANK YOU!

  • wei shiue
    wei shiue 3 aylar önce +1044

    I just wondered what will happen if Dr. B is in charge of task force back in 2020 instead of Dr. Fauci.

  • Barbara Louise Benjamin
    Barbara Louise Benjamin 3 aylar önce +115

    A brilliant interview. Thankyou for being the voice of reason. May you be heard.

  • Jesus My Savior
    Jesus My Savior 3 aylar önce +111

    Thank you so much Dr. Jay! My heart is sunken and heavy seeing what’s happening in our country to our people, I cry…

  • Karen S
    Karen S 2 aylar önce +37

    Jay is one of the few with courage; thanks Peter for bringing him to us.
    Please comment back on what he thinks of using the vaccines with the current dominance of wild type variants. Thanks to you both.

  • ESSM
    ESSM 3 aylar önce +68

    What a great conversation. Thank you Peter and thank you Dr Jay Bhattacharya. You are a gem of a person.

  • Scott Carl
    Scott Carl 3 aylar önce +99

    Excellent.

    If you look at each question through the lens of entropy and fear, you will be able to predict the outcome.
    Should we lock down? Yes, increases fear.
    Should we move sick seniors back into the assisted living centers? Yes, increases entropy.
    Should we investigate true IFR? No, it would decrease entropy.

    Thank you Dr. Bhattacharya

  • Peter Loxham
    Peter Loxham 2 aylar önce +85

    Peter, such a big thanks for a well balanced and incisive discussion into a world problem. We will never be given an apology by world health for making such catastrophic decisions based on fear rather than fact!

  • Praneet Singh Butran
    Praneet Singh Butran 3 aylar önce +283

    WOWOWOOW, I am the first here to comment on the latest episode of the fantastic Pete Robinson's UnCKnowledge! You are truly doing a service to mankind, what a range of intellectual awesomeness!

  • Donna Manuel
    Donna Manuel 2 aylar önce +19

    It felt so good to hear the scientific facts and truths that I now can sleep tonight knowing that I no longer feel confused. I'll wake up in the morning feeling so much stronger than I have been since that so called pandemic began. Thank you gentlemen. ❤️

  • Marco Williams
    Marco Williams 2 aylar önce +56

    Thank you both. A balanced reasoned interview that lays bare as ridiculous all the silly mandates, and rules that have been imposed on us - often without any justification and in some cases, with no discernible logic.

  • Mickey Constam
    Mickey Constam 2 aylar önce +30

    So great to hear Dr. Jay at length! I appreciate his expertise and common sense approach. Have seen him a number of times on Ingraham, but the format only affords him a couple of sound bytes. Thank you for this informative discussion!

  • Yoon Jeongsoo
    Yoon Jeongsoo 3 aylar önce +845

    this is the most important video I have seen in the past 19 months

  • Zach Scott
    Zach Scott 2 aylar önce +68

    Thank you for this interview and it’s so great to hear a really intelligent and thoughtful discussion of many colossal failures that just happen to be coincidental. Brett Weinstein said a quote the other day that bears repeating, “just follow the silence”

  • Mooshin
    Mooshin 2 aylar önce +53

    As a pro-vaccination person this discussion gave me fresh and quite an interesting perspective. Thank you.

  • Ruhmheim
    Ruhmheim 3 aylar önce +241

    Finally an face to face interview! I can't believe it..Feels so good

  • Beck Beck
    Beck Beck 3 aylar önce +26

    what a brilliant presentation by medical professionals qualified that makes sense on issues to combat covid. Thanks Hoover Instituation for bring this out.

  • Sandra W
    Sandra W 2 aylar önce +70

    Thank you for this discussion but I have a few questions. If the man who invented this type of "vaccine" recommends not to use it then what argument do y'all have that we should? Also, y'all are really informed and smart,and with that being said I would really be interested in hearing about an indepth analysis concerning the the side effects of this actual "experimental vaccine". Not that my opinion counts for much but y'all assume that Dr. "F" has our best intentions at heart which I don't agree with.
    Again thank you.

  • Jody
    Jody 3 aylar önce +179

    Fantastic interview, really appreciate Uncommonknowledge

  • herinsh
    herinsh 3 aylar önce +139

    Very thought provoking, thanks for the bold share. I must wonder how could you get this so wrong? Perhaps it was no accident. Will history remember Fauci & the WHO in the same sentence as Mengala?

  • kosmotrekker
    kosmotrekker 2 aylar önce +80

    Great interview with a really honest scientist who dares to tell everybody ( including the establishment )
    the truth of what is happening with this epidemic. Great job Hoover Institution !

  • Darvistas
    Darvistas 2 aylar önce +24

    This channel is brilliant.. I've watch for 18 months.. placing covid in context, where any journaliat and scientist with integrity should..bravo.

  • Yoon Jeongsoo
    Yoon Jeongsoo 3 aylar önce +86

    Thank you to the Hoover Institution for this interview as well as the one with Dr. Atlas many months ago. I swear, when I get rich enough I will start donating to you guys.

  • S P
    S P 3 aylar önce +50

    Mr. Robinson and Dr. Bhattacharya - thank you so much. My heartfelt gratitude for both of you.

  • Petro Bowen
    Petro Bowen 2 aylar önce +68

    At last another very highly intelligent person that did research and is now revealing true facts, well done and thank you for your hard work. RESEARCH AINT EASY, ITS HARD WORK !!!!

  • Dina Armeni
    Dina Armeni 3 aylar önce +158

    Best interview ever. Hopefully things will change

  • Jason Lovato
    Jason Lovato 3 aylar önce +96

    Strangely, I have friends that are very intelligent and educated that still think the lock downs were okay.

  • Muskett
    Muskett 2 aylar önce +63

    I'm from the UK. This is the best interview that reflects my views. Thank you.

  • soapbxprod
    soapbxprod 3 aylar önce +61

    Thank you once again, Mr. Robinson and Dr. Bhattacharya. Hoover Institution is our last greatest hope for reason to prevail over superstition.

  • kwakaman555
    kwakaman555 2 aylar önce +24

    Thanks for a high quality discussion. Both elected officials and unelected bureaucrats have willfully avoided high quality debates, in itself disturbing to witness...

  • Mary-anne
    Mary-anne 3 aylar önce +70

    Thank you this brought me more hope again. This idea of focused protection is one I've felt is best right from the beginning. I enjoyed the whole video, I hope some people that should watch it do.

  • Emily Allan
    Emily Allan 2 aylar önce +32

    Very important conversation. Thank you for posting this and thank you to TR-cam for not censoring it.

  • praise songs
    praise songs 3 aylar önce +27

    Thank u for this wonderful interview, it confirms all that I have experienced and concluded from scientific data and physician statements!!!

  • Carrie Sweeney
    Carrie Sweeney 2 aylar önce +29

    Love this Dr! Thank you so much for speaking out! You are THE VOICE OF REASON!!!

  • SCWgreg
    SCWgreg 3 aylar önce +47

    Please also post this on Odysee and Local platforms, to thwart censorship. Spot on, calm, logical, common sense. What about data from VAERS? What about alternative treatments? More research here please. Thank you.

  • Erik Metzger
    Erik Metzger 3 aylar önce +158

    Dr. Jay is the best. He's too good for the farm.

  • elizabeth haas
    elizabeth haas 3 aylar önce +44

    This discussion has been very enlightening. Thank you

  • Marilyn S
    Marilyn S 2 aylar önce +75

    This is the most trustworthy and credible piece I’ve heard about COVID! Thank you for speaking honestly.

  • Water Gun
    Water Gun 3 aylar önce +36

    Thank you Peter and Dr Jay. Very important work.

  • Jim Wilson
    Jim Wilson 3 aylar önce +46

    Thank you gor such a great interview. I wish were broadcast through more mainstream channels.

  • Merlin3189
    Merlin3189 3 aylar önce +73

    Thank you for this wonderful, clear calm and sensible discussion of one of the biggest man-made disasters in human history. I found it very moving.

    The discussion of the 'Precautionary Principle' highlighted something that worried me throughout the pandemic. No one in government nor in WHO ever discussed the harmful effects of their policies. Only the benefits - claimed or hoped for - of their chosen policies were ever mentioned. Outside experts such as Dr. B. himself, but including all sorts of experts outside government and even one UNESCO scientist, pointed out some of the harms, but it seems these were never even considered by the policymakers.
    It parallels the current climate policies. There could be some dangers from climate change and the governments have decided they must act, not to mitigate these dangers, but to dabble in climate manipulation, which, even if they are right, will only slow the increase in climate related damage. We get never ending recitals of the harms that could come from a small change in climate, but I've never heard a government spokesman or climate activist say anything about the real consequences of the astronomical costs of climate control.

    • Mary Valli
      Mary Valli 2 aylar önce +5

      Excellent point

    • arttytsai
      arttytsai 3 aylar önce +8

      This reflects Thomas Sowell’s sentiment, always asks the question,”but at what cost?”

  • judge4all
    judge4all 3 aylar önce +213

    I agree w/ the gd Dr. ‘fear is more powerful than placebo”.

  • Ramy Barrett
    Ramy Barrett 2 aylar önce +28

    Thanks for an outstanding and educational interviews!!! Congratulations!🏆

  • Richard Billings
    Richard Billings 2 aylar önce +13

    Amazing! Thank you for your lucid and frank discussion of the issues and applying common sense. These discussions are needed in a broader medium and are not happening. Thanks again.

  • HIPNICITY
    HIPNICITY 3 aylar önce +139

    Thank you for differentiation between vaccines & COVID vaccines! But I still don’t think it’s worth the risk to take the injection.

  • Nolie Abriol
    Nolie Abriol 2 aylar önce +31

    Thanks so much, i wish you are the head of the UN you have a lot of common sense, and a very caring person. My decision is not to be vaccinated. I think this is just crazy, when you are forcing the vaccines to the people. Gob Bless You Dr. B and Hoover.

  • LM G
    LM G 2 aylar önce +15

    Thank you both gentlemen, a wonderful open discussion.

  • Julie Lumsden
    Julie Lumsden 2 aylar önce +15

    This discussion is the most sensible I’ve listened to in a very long time. Thankyou very much

  • Irene Jennings
    Irene Jennings 2 aylar önce +13

    Finally some truth and common sense!! Thank you!

  • Ben Lloyd
    Ben Lloyd 3 aylar önce +135

    My two favourite people in one show!

  • Al Wilk
    Al Wilk 3 aylar önce +44

    This was a real eye opener, thank you.

  • desertskymike
    desertskymike 2 aylar önce +10

    Dr. Bhattacharya, thank you very much for all of your good work. And thank you Peter Robinson for all the intelligent discussion that you provide the public.

  • dave
    dave 2 aylar önce +26

    Thank you Dr. J (now I have 2 idols named Dr. J), and Peter for a great interview. Broadcasting like this is so needed and important. ✌️

  • Irena Magdalena
    Irena Magdalena 2 aylar önce +32

    OMG, I’m so grateful for this interview 😊 Thank you 🙏

  • Tom DiVittis
    Tom DiVittis 2 aylar önce +10

    Fantastic interview. A heartfelt thank you to both host and guest.

  • Margaret Hess
    Margaret Hess 2 aylar önce +15

    What a gracious and enlightening interview. Thank you!

  • 1974jrod
    1974jrod 3 aylar önce +228

    80 percent of the deaths were over 65, AND 80 percent of those were staying home.